No Good Choices

By Glenn Davis

Rahab was an amazing woman.  She abandoned her society and all that she knew to risk her life to save two strangers who were spying for a foreign nation.  She chose to take a daring stand with God and His people.  Yet because of her method she has been harshly criticized by Christian leaders for the last 2,000 years.

Sometimes, as we face the problems and situations of life, there are no good choices.  Does God condemn us for making the best choice we can even when it is

There is no escaping the fact - she lied.  She had no good choices, so she chose to lie.  And although she is praised in the New Testament with no criticism of her methods, she has been ill-treated by writers ever since.  Some condemn her outright.  Others try to explain away her lie with things like she was a new believer coming from a corrupt society and so didn’t realize that lying was wrong.  Or her heart was in the right place, but her methods were wrong.  The majority conclusion seems to be that she should have told the truth to the soldiers [or said nothing which would have had the same effect] and trusted God to take care of the results.  

Rahab was placed in a difficult situation by evil men where there were no good choices.  If she told the truth it is almost certain the spies would have been executed and she would have lost her opportunity of joining the people of God.  To keep silent would be to admit involvement, the spies most likely would have been found and she certainly would have been arrested if not executed on the spot.  The third choice was deception which involved lying.  

No Good Choices

To say that God would have supernaturally intervened if Rahab had chosen to tell the truth is to make a very big assumption.  Supernatural intervention is the exception, not the rule.  It is to fall into the same error as the medieval Trial By Combat or Trial By Ordeal.  The idea behind these “trials” was that God [or nature] would allow the innocent person be victorious [Combat] or escape harm [Ordeal].  Needless to say, this is not a Biblical concept.  God expects His people to stand for what they know is true, right and according to the will of God.

Follow justice and justice alone, so that you may live and possess the land the Lord your God is giving you.  Deut. 16:20, NIV

Learn to do right; seek justice.  Defend the oppressed.  Take up the cause of the fatherless;  plead the case of the widow. Is. 1:17, NIV 

In this place, Rahab had no good choices.  In the absence of a direct word from God, she had to evaluate what was most likely to happen from each decision.  Then she had to choose the one which would probably have a result that was pleasing to God and a positive impact on the Kingdom of God.  

To some this may sound like “the end justifies the means” or situational ethics.  That is not the case.  Rahab did not make her choice to lie because it was the easy, fast or painless way to achieve “the end” goal.  She made it because it was the only choice available that would not involve a greater evil.  Nor was she saying that something that is normally wrong was right just because of the situation.  [We discuss whether lying was a sin in this situation in our article: Responsible Lying.]  She was looking at the available options and taking the only one that was likely to have God-honouring results.

Rahab and the spies

Rahab chose to accept responsibility for her actions.  She chose to risk her life.  She chose to deceive evil men bent on an evil purpose in order to protect Godly men operating in the will of God.  The fact that she is commended in both the Old and New Testaments without criticism of her deception, which was a necessary part of her actions, shows God’s approval.  Self-righteous Christians who refuse to make difficult choices to help innocent and oppressed people because “God will intervene if He wants to” are acting irresponsibly.  They are avoiding their own discomfort and blaming God for the results.  

Living in a sin-filled world, there may be times when we are placed in evil circumstances where there are no good choices.  Sometimes, even in political voting, we are making the least bad choice because no good choices exist.  If we find ourselves placed in bad situations - whether by evil governments, abusive spouses, criminals, or others - we have to carefully consider the Word of God and which “bad” choice will result in honouring God, expanding the Kingdom of God and/or protecting the innocent from injustice and harm.

“For I, the Lord, love justice; I hate robbery and wrongdoing.  In my faithfulness I will reward my people and make an everlasting covenant with them.  Is. 61:8, NIV

Rahab took responsibility and great risk to see justice done and God did indeed reward her.  She was able to join the Israelite community, marry a Godly man, and became an ancestor to both King David and Jesus Christ Himself.  Plus her actions - which were a result of her faith - are held up as an example of Godly action for all time.

For more information about Glenn Davis see our About Glenn page and/or his Author's Page.

Adventure story: The Disappearance of Captain Danson.

You might like these

  • God Is In Control Working Everything For Good

    God is in control although many times, through pain-filled eyes, it seems like situations have slipped through His hands. We wonder, Does God care? and Where is God in the bad times?

  • No Word From God Will Ever Fail

    We can rest in confidence that no Word from God will ever fail. His Word stands sure!

  • Indiscreet Importunity

    Indiscreet importunity: Sometimes God will give us our own way even against His perfect will. We always end up hurting ourselves. It is much better to be submitted to the will of God.

  • How To Build Your Ark

    God wants you to build your ark, but how do you build your ark? How do you know what it is God really wants?

  • On God's Terms

    Why did Elisha not accept Naaman's gifts? What was there about God's terms that made it necessary?

  • Are We On God's Side?

    Are we on God's side or are we only interested if He is on our side?

  • How To Be Like Jesus

    Discover how to be like Jesus. Leave your works behind and enter into the joy of becoming like Jesus. Nothing else will do.

  • How To Be Like Christ

    Discover how to be like Christ. Leave your works behind and enter into the joy of becoming like Jesus. Nothing else will do.

  • How To Become Like Christ

    Discover how to become like Christ. Leave your works behind and enter into the joy of becoming like Jesus. Nothing else will do.

  • The Acts Of God

    Do we see the acts of God or do we press in to discover the ways of God?

New! Comments

Have your say about what you just read! Leave me a comment in the box below.
Would you like to see what we have written on a subject? Use the search below.

Lookup a word or passage in the Bible
Include this form on your page